+48 602 388 200 [email protected]

Poland Krakow Auschwitz Birkenau Report of blind visitor

Can we turn a blind eye to Auschwitz?

This is the tenth delegation with NW Regional Members but the 28th that Sefton Local Government Branch has organised.

When I was given the opportunity to go on this visit, I went into it with my eyes wide open,
knowing there would be challenges, but wanting to learn more about the history.

Day 1 – Jewish Quarter Tour
Our trip began bright and early as we set off on a walking tour around Krakow, specifically
the Jewish districts of Kazimierz and Podgorze. The sun was shining and it promised to be a
warm and sunny day, not at all like we had planned for in our clothes packing.

Scattered throughout Kazimierz are remnants of a tragically turbulent past, solemn synagogues and poignant memorial sites. The area exuded a sense of history, with its cobbled streets and the sound of horses’ hooves echoing off the tall buildings.
We stopped for a time of reflection in the main square at a memorial with a stone plaque describing it as a ‘Place of Meditation’ upon the martyrdom of 88 thousand Polish Citizens of Jewish nationality from Krakow, and its environs, culled by Nazis during World War 2. We listened as Anita our Guide, told us about the history of the area, what life had been like, and explained the functions of the various buildings.

Incorporated into a bench outside the ‘Remuh ’ (Synagogue) was a statue of Jan Karski (1914 – 2000) with an accompanying plaque detailing his role from 1940 – 1943, as the emissary of the Polish people in German occupied Poland to the Polish Government in exile and to the Governments of France, the United Kingdom and the United States of America. A man who tried to stop the Holocaust of Polish Jews. Righteous among the nations. Honorary citizen of Israel awarded the Polish Order of the White Eagle and American Presidential Medal of Freedom.

We were able to enter the only remaining active synagogue in Krakow to take in the splendour of the architecture and ambience. Because it is still an active synagogue, it was reflecting real life with Jews in there going through their prayers and rituals, so devout and sincere. It seemed they found a great deal of comfort and refuge in their prayers. To me it felt peaceful and like it was
a sanctuary – a place to come and just ‘be’. There were carvings of the Menorah and the stones representing the 12 tribes of Israel, a great deal of time and skill had been spent making this building a fitting place for the Jewish population to come and spend their time practicing their religious ceremonies. We were honoured to meet the custodian of the synagogue, Adam, who is the son of one of the Schindler Jews. He opened the doors to where the Torah was kept, which was a privilege indeed.

From there we walked down the cobbled streets to ‘The Old Syn’, or ‘Galicja Museum’, which is the oldest synagogue in Poland. Showcasing the beauty of its Gothic-Renaissance interior, with stone, marble and iron work, the skills of the builders was evident all around. During our visit we had the extra special treat of a group of Jews entering the building who began singing some authentic a’capella chants. As it was not a planned concert, I was honoured to have been in the right place at the right time. it truly was an amazing experience; I was captivated by the sounds as it echoed all around with beautiful singing. I won’t forget this experience as it really brought the
building to life for me with the amazing acoustics.

Crossing the Vistula River to Podgorze, over the ‘Bridge of Love’ with its many padlocks attached to represent love, I was struck by how the human race, although it can inflict such atrocities on its fellow humans, can always rise up and turn what has been a bleak and evil past into a symbol of
hope – opposite to what the area is about – not cancelling out or sweeping the past under the carpet, but refusing to allow the past to dictate the future, instead, learning from it; turning it into something good. To quote George Santayana, (16 th December 1863 – 26 th September 1952), ‘Those who do not remember the past are condemned to repeat it.’

After the Nazi German invasion of Poland in September 1939 the Jews in Krakow and surrounding areas were deliberately targeted for cruelty and ‘special treatment’. They were forced out of their homes and herded into a ‘ghetto’ in Podgorze, living in disgusting overcrowded conditions. It became a hive of illnesses, people and deprivation of rights and liberties. Virtually all Jewish life and culture in Poland was destroyed. 88,000 people were crammed into this small area of the city. We followed the Ghetto memory trail, listening as Anita told of the unthinkable horrors carried out during this period of time.

The German Occupiers ordered the Jews to build a wall around the ghetto. This wall was built in the shape of gravestones, subliminally foretelling their destiny.

Ghetto Heroes Square (Plac Bohaterow Getta) was once the main square of the Ghetto and where the Nazis would choose which Jewish prisoners were to travel to the death camps. Today, it is home to ‘The Empty Chairs Memorial’, composed of numerous empty iron chairs of several sizes
that commemorate the atrocities committed here. In the same square stands ‘Under the Eagle Pharmacy’; the only pharmacy permitted to operate in the Ghetto, which helped many Jews survive during their captivity.

Following on from lunch, (in the restaurant where Stephen Speilberg ate during the filming of ‘Schindler’s List’) we had some light relief in the form of a visit up Wawel Hill, where Kraków’s medieval castle and palace complex dominates the city’s skyline on all sides. an imposing and symbolic image of the city’s medieval might and superlative architecture. We were given the opportunity to climb the many gruelling flights of wooden steps up Sigismund's Tower, squeezing through the beams, it was like potholing up stairs, to reach the infamous Sigismund Bell – a resounding symbol of Polish nationalism. The largest by far of five bells hanging in the same tower, Sigismund's Bell weighs in at an astounding 12.6 total tonnes, measures 241cm in height, 242cm across at the lip and varies from 7 to 21cm thick. The bronze beauty was cast in 1520 on the orders of King Sigismund I and is adorned in reliefs of St. Stanisław and St. Sigismund as well as the coat of arms of Poland and Lithuania. We had the chance to touch the clapper and make a wish before descending the tower.

We made our way down through the streets of Krakow to the main square where we heard the Bugler in the Clock Tower, play what is known in Polish as the hejnał mariacki, which is one of Kraków’s most famous traditions. It is played – on the hour, every hour – from the window on each of the four sides of the taller of the church’s two towers. The tradition dates back to at
least the 14th century. According to more recent mythology, it was inspired by a heroic bugler who warned of invading forces but was killed by an arrow mid-tune – hence why today’s call also ends abruptly. Historically, the call was used to warn Kraków residents about fires or invasions, as well as marking the opening and closing of the city gates. Only much more recently did it become an hourly tradition. The hejnał is directed first in the direction of Wawel Royal Castle, to symbolise playing for the king; then towards the market square, for city councillors; then to the Florian Gate, for guests; and finally in the direction of the fire department headquarters.

As I walked through the streets of Krakow I was very much aware of all the different languages, it felt very multi-cultural, so different from what it would have been only 80 years ago.

Day 2 – Auschwitz 1 – ARBEIT MACHT FREI – Work Sets You Free
As we stepped onto the bus for our journey to Auschwitz 1, melancholy music played, which seemed to me was being purposely played to ‘get us into the ‘appropriate’ mood’. A film was shown on the outgoing journey, but as I listened to the commentary, in my mind it felt more like a
celebration of what Hitler had done, I felt as though I was being manipulated into emotion as
if it was staged. To me, the commentary seemed to applaud Hitler’s conquests, and hearing 3 rd Reich propaganda sounded like a recruitment video. It was hushed on the bus as the video played, reducing talkative people to silence.

I was surprised by the level of security needed in order to enter the memorial site. Airport style security with x ray and scanning machines and we needed to produce our passports. I don’t know whether this was because there are still people out there who would like to destroy any evidence of such a place, in denial that any of the horrors had ever happened, or whether it was to heighten our sense of the unknown, perhaps giving a sense of what the Jewish prisoners would have felt.

Our entrance to the site involved walking down a 12-foot-high concrete wall corridor listening
to names on a roll call of the people who been murdered, Again, was this to add to the experience, to help us empathise with those who had gone before us? Purposely giving a sense of how they must have felt? Building the anticipation. I can’t see anything. Where am I going?

I was surprised because there were brick buildings, – well-built solid structures with high ceilings. Where were the wooden huts? This was nothing like my mind’s eye and imagination envisioned, however, Mirek explained that this was a former Polish army barracks. They were very clinical,
painted, windows, with electric lights for exhibiting photos, so for me it was difficult to envision it as a place of suffering. The sun was shining and the sky was blue, I don’t know whether this had an effect on how I perceived the area.

One of the blocks housed an exhibition of Jewish life, as it had been. But towards the end of the exhibition, was a film reel of the kind of prejudice, intolerance and fascism the Jewish population faced. It made me angry, hearing the words of Hitler being broadcast. I felt they should never have the words of such evil people being spoken out loud ever again, as to me it was propaganda. However, I understand that it needed to be shown because we needed to hear what was being said in order to feel the anger and emotion to stir us up to ensure this must not happen again.

We entered a building which before the war was a munition bunker. From 15 August 1940 to July 1943, the SS used it as a crematorium. In the autumn of 1941, the largest room, which had been designed by the camp authorities as a morgue, was adapted for use as an improvised gas chamber, the first of Its kind in Auschwitz. Using the gas produced by pellets of Zyklon B, many thousands of Jews were murdered here by the SS within hours of their arrival at Auschwitz. Several groups of Soviet POWs were also murdered here in this way, as were sick prisoners whose return to work was considered unlikely. Poles from outside the camp who had been sentenced to death by the German summary court were shot here. After the establishment In Auschwitz I-Birkenau of two more improvised gas chambers in spring and summer of 1942 for the mass murder of the Jews, the gassings here were gradually stopped. The building was subsequently utilised for storage, and then as an air-raid shelter for the SS. After the war, the Museum partially reconstructed the gas chamber and crematorium. The chimney and two incinerators were rebuilt using original components, as were several of the openings in the gas chamber roof. It was bone chilling in there, I touched the walls and imagined the terror the prisoners would have felt.

After having spent the morning there, I was still asking why do people visit here?

My question was answered that afternoon. We held a short ceremony at the infamous ‘Death Wall’ where prisoners were shot against a cork wall—the cork prevented ricochets against the SS men carrying out the executions. This was a very important part of the visit where each of us laid a rose to remember those who had lost their lives and a wreath from NW Unison was also laid. It was a sombre moment and an honour to be a part of. I was very proud to represent Unison and the disabled members of Unison. I would have been part of his experiment.

Following on from our memorial ceremony, we went in to another block where there was a display of the Book of names. The names of the murdered are inscribed in this book as an eternal memorial. The names and life span of 4.8 million people who were murdered by the Nazis, and blank pages symbolising another 1.2 million whose names have not yet been recovered. The scale of the display was extremely moving, highlighting the magnitude of the atrocities.

Day 3 – Auschwitz 2 known as ‘Birkenau’.
Another early start and another coach journey with a video. The weather was damp and
misty, as though it was trying to match the mood we felt in anticipation of this visit. Bleak,
barren and overcast.

First view is of the train track leading up to the main gate and lookout tower. Birkenau was a purpose built factory of death on a massive scale with 4 Gas Chambers and attached crematoria. The imposing watchtower and railway track saw hundreds of thousands of people, mainly Jews, from all over Europe brought here in cattle trucks and sent straight to the Gas Chambers. ‘Selection’ on the ramp divided the living from those about to die. The average length of survival at Birkenau was 3 months.

Our first port of call was to go up the watchtower. I was very aware that I was walking over the footsteps of evil; actually grabbing the handrail of the stairs that murderers have touched, it
made me angry. From here it was possible to look out over the whole area and appreciate the vastness of landscape, with its guard towers and multiple rows of barbed wire fencing, stretching
across the field to the low lying buildings, some had been razed to the ground, in an attempt to remove evidence, but gave the appearance of large, freshly dug grave plots. These were the huts I had expected to see. These huts were originally built to house around 50 horses, but instead, more than 400 prisoners were crammed into 3 storey bunks. Auschwitz 1 was ‘the template’— whatever
worked there was replicated at Birkenau (Auschwitz II) on an industrial scale—you will never forget the sheer size of Birkenau.

Trains with deported Jews arrived at the railway siding, crammed in with their prized possessions, which would have been confiscated upon arrival. The railway siding was known as ‘The Place of Selection’. Usually 70 to 75 per cent of the Jews arriving on the transports were immediately sent to be murdered in the gas chambers here. The decision given to send them left or right, indicated by a simple thumb up, or thumb down. Those the SS selected from among the mass of arrivals who were considered strong and healthy enough to work were interned in the concentration camp Birkenau or in the other parts of the Auschwitz complex. It was not intended that they should be reprieved from the death sentence, but rather that they should contribute their labour to the German war effort until they died from starvation, exhaustion, or disease.

As I walked alongside the train tracks to the Place of Selection, I could hear the sounds of footsteps walking all around me, bringing to life a sense of what they would have been experiencing. Multi languages, silence, crying, shouting. Simulating the sounds of the people walking to their ultimate destiny. I felt I was walking in the steps of dead men, women and children. It was very sobering. When you got off the train and saw the skeletal emaciated people standing there. What would be going through your head? Once again, I realised my life would have immediately ended there.

We made our way to the far side of the Birkenau Camp to the ‘Memorial to the Victims of Fascism’, the ‘sauna’ building and the remains of Crematoria 4. As we passed through the camp, there were many groups holding vigils and memorials, showing respect and pledging to make a difference when they returned to ‘real life’.

Whilst walking to our next memorial point, I was conscious of the immense landscape, surrounded by forest. I was struck by a passing comment Mirek made, ‘The trees are witnesses’: Silver Poplar, Birch and Oak. I wanted to walk through the silent witnesses, it was serene, tranquil, sombre, reflective; seemingly at odds with all that had gone on there in the past. Nature soothing, but a tangible reminder of all that had occurred. I feel I gained more of an understanding regarding why Halton Unison have planted a Birch tree in remembrance; a time of reflection is held at the tree annually each Holocaust Memorial Day.

We placed lanterns with lit candles to remember those who revolted in October 1944. As I stood reflecting, I could hear birdsong, and it once again reminded me that there is still good in this world and I must play my part in that.

This report is just the tip of the iceberg in what was an incredible and thought-provoking trip.
Yes, there were sombre and subdued moments, but there was also the chance to get to
know my fellow unison members and be reminded that there are more people who want to
work for good than evil. In the words of Edmund Burke (12 January 1729 – 9 July 1797),
‘The only thing necessary for evil to triumph in the world is that good men do nothing.’

This trip has inspired me to stand up for the rights of those who cannot do this themselves,
but also recognise the good that is in the world around us, darkness will not win.

I would like to thank David and Ingrid from my Unison Branch – Halton, for the sponsorship
and all the support they have given me in order for me to attend.

Thanks to Glen Williams, The organiser from Sefton Branch, who from the moment I stepped
into the airport to depart, to stepping back into the UK, had organised the whole trip
impeccably. We knew where we had to be and when.

Our tour guide – Mirek, accompanied us around the two Auschwitz camps, explaining the
exhibits and describing the various artefacts, but also adding his own anecdotes from people
he had spoken to, who were living witness to the atrocities.

Anita was our guide throughout the trip. Both were exemplary and brought much insight to the trip, their knowledge, explanations and attention to detail was second to none. Their oratory skills brought it to life.

Thanks to Helen, my PA. who enabled me to experience the whole trip in every sense of the word. There would have been occasions when people must have wondered what that mad man was doing running  his hands all over the walls, displays and artefacts! We successfully navigated our way across the miles, keeping me engaged and informed, pointing out and describing artefacts that I wasn’t able to access by touch, and thank you most of all for not leaving me there and getting me home safely.

Finally, in answer to the question which is the title of this report – Can we turn a blind eye to Auschwitz? I think the answer is yes. Yes we can metaphorically, but it would be remiss, if not negligent to do so. We must ensure this must never happen again and by encouraging as many people as possible to embark on a Holocaust Educational tour, in order to be spurred on to make a difference, that is what it is all about.

Can we turn a blind eye to Auschwitz? Physically, that is what I have done. I am registered blind. I wasn’t sure what to expect to feel during this tour, would I be able to fully participate and feel the full depth and range of the experience, albeit non visually? Birkenau was beginning to add in more accessible features for visually impaired visitors; a large model of the grounds of the Auschwitz I and Auschwitz II-Birkenau, cast in bronze, to help imagine the spatial dimensions of the Memorial, and an information system using the Braille alphabet.  I may not be able see with my eyes but I can experience the world with my entire self. I can hear and touch and feel (physically and emotionally) and even taste (the food was delicious!) my way through everything this trip had
to offer. My eyes were opened to learning. I have touched history, and history has touched me. So again, the answer is yes.

⠠⠓⠑⠇⠑⠝⠀⠠⠊⠇⠇⠊⠙⠛⠑ ⇒ Patrick Joseph Toner “Paddy”

Helen Illidge ‘Ghost Writer’

What are you looking for?